Why people leave Google Analytics
Someone who uses ReaderCount put it to me well: Google Analytics takes forever to find the basic information. That's the most common reason I hear. Google Analytics 4 is built for advertisers and online shops, so the simple questions sit behind reports, explorations and settings.
The other reasons come up again and again:
- The cookie banner. Google Analytics needs consent in the EU and usually in the UK, and readers who click No aren't counted.
- Missing readers. Many ad blockers stop Google Analytics loading at all.
- Privacy. Some readers, and some writers, would rather Google didn't see every visit.
- Page weight. The Google tag is much heavier than a simple stats script.
What a blogger actually needs
| Question | What answers it |
|---|---|
| How many people read me? | Visitors and page views, by day, week and month |
| Which posts do they read? | Top pages, with time on page |
| Where did they come from? | Sources: Google, social networks, newsletters, other sites |
| What did they search for? | Google Search Console figures, ideally next to your visitors |
| Did my newsletter or post work? | Campaign tags and goals such as sign-ups |
| Does it earn anything? | Affiliate link clicks and, ideally, earnings per post |
If a tool answers those on one page, you'll actually look at it. That matters more than any feature list.
The alternatives at a glance
I've kept to tools I know well, and I've left prices out because they change. Check each tool's own website for current plans and limits.
| Tool | Cookies | Hosting | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|
| Plausible | None | Their cloud, or self-hosted Community Edition | A clean single-page dashboard, open source |
| Fathom | None | Their cloud | Simple, polished stats with generous limits |
| Simple Analytics | None | Their cloud | A minimal tool with a strong privacy stance |
| Matomo | Optional | Self-hosted or their cloud | The nearest thing to Google Analytics, with full control of your data |
| Umami | None | Self-hosted or their cloud | Developers happy to run their own server |
| Cloudflare Web Analytics | None | Cloudflare | A free, very basic count if you're already on Cloudflare |
| ReaderCount | None | Our cloud, or self-hosted on your own Cloudflare account | Bloggers and publishers: searches, clicks and earnings per post |
Each one in a sentence or two
Plausible
Plausible made the one-page dashboard popular, and it's still one of the clearest to read. It's open source, so you can run it yourself if you prefer. There's a side-by-side with ReaderCount.
Fathom
Fathom is a well-made, simple tool that's been around a long time and is reliable. There's a side-by-side with ReaderCount.
Simple Analytics
Simple Analytics does what it says: the essentials, presented plainly, with privacy at the centre. There's a side-by-side with ReaderCount.
Matomo
Matomo is the full-featured option, closest to Google Analytics in what it can do, and open source. That also means more to learn. You can switch its cookies off, which changes how it counts returning visitors.
Umami
Umami is a light, open source tool that's popular with developers who run their own servers. It's simple and fast, with fewer reports made for writers.
Cloudflare Web Analytics
If your site already uses Cloudflare, you can switch this on for free. It counts visits and pages without cookies, but it's basic: no goals, no Google searches and limited detail on sources.
ReaderCount
I built ReaderCount for people who write. Alongside the usual visitors, pages and sources, it shows your Google searches next to each post, counts affiliate link clicks without any setup, brings in earnings from networks such as Awin and Amazon reports, and emails you a short list of posts worth fixing each Monday. It's free, and you can try the live demo without signing up.
How to choose
| If you… | Look at |
|---|---|
| Just want a clean count, nothing else | Plausible, Fathom, Simple Analytics or Cloudflare Web Analytics |
| Want everything Google Analytics does, but private | Matomo |
| Want to run it on your own server | Plausible Community Edition, Matomo, Umami or self-hosted ReaderCount |
| Write a blog or newsletter and earn from it | ReaderCount |
| Use WordPress and want it in your Dashboard | Most have a plugin; ReaderCount's is in the WordPress directory |
Whatever you pick, run it alongside Google Analytics for a few weeks first. You'll see the difference in your figures, and you'll find out whether you actually open it.
How to switch without losing history
- Add the new tool's script to your site and leave Google Analytics running for now.
- Export your old figures. Google Analytics lets you download reports as a spreadsheet. Some tools, ReaderCount included, can import your older monthly visitors so your chart doesn't start from zero.
- Connect Google Search Console if your new tool supports it.
- Compare for two to four weeks. Expect the new tool to show more visitors, not fewer.
- Remove Google Analytics, update your privacy policy and, if nothing else needs it, take down your cookie banner. The cookie banner guide covers that last part.
Questions
Will I lose anything by leaving Google Analytics?
You lose detailed audience reports, such as age and interests, which come from Google's advertising data, and some of the deeper funnels. Most bloggers never use them.
Can I use two stats tools at once?
Yes. Small cookie-free scripts are light enough that running two side by side won't slow your site.
Why do the alternatives show more visitors?
Because they count readers who refused cookies or block Google. The guide to why the numbers differ explains it.
Free for one website. No card needed.